Note: aceste informații sumarizează, în varianta de rezumat, datele de care dispunem la nivelul luniii iulie 2022, pentru acest Obiectiv specific al Proiectului ”Pacient român – legi juste și transparență maximă”.
Brief description of the need for the solution
FACIAS ran the "Be informed, not abused!" project between April amd February 2022.
These issues were revealed, particularly by the approximately 1000 responses to the FACIAS Questionnaire and the over 3000 messages received."
One of the five key difficulties mentioned for which we were asked for citize support in the Health domain is:
- Accesul facil la Istoricul medical propriu (Dosarul medical electronic -pentru tot istoricul, așa cum ar trebui să funcționeze DESI)
UPDATED OFFICIAL INFORMATION:
- Source: National Health Insurance House (CNAS)
Electronic medical record – information available at: http://www.des-cnas.ro/pub/
Contact: CNAS – Calea Calarasilor 248, Bl. S19, Sector 3, 030634 Bucuresti
Gestionar Dosar Electronic de Sănătate (DES): CNAS
The health record for a patient is created when a doctor first sends a medical document to the DES system.
DES (new version) is active from December 15, 2021
DES (Health File) is organized into 5 sections:
- Summary for emergency situations
- Medical history
- Antecedents declared by the patient
- Medical documents
- Personal data
- DES: benefits and advantages for: Patients/Doctors/Institutions: http://www.des-cnas.ro/wps/portal/cnas/BeneficiiPatients/Doctors/Institutions http://www.des-cnas.ro/wps/portal/cnas/Beneficii
- DES: Intrebări Frecvente : http://www.des-cnas.ro/wps/portal/cnas/FAQ/!ut/p/a1/04_Sj9CPykssy0xPLMnMz0vMAfGjzOK9LHyMPJwtjLzcnU1cDBy9vS2C_Z08DDxNjYAKIoEKDHAARwNC-sP1o8BKzAwtTTycLAy8DdzcgUpMjEyDgrwtjYB8qAI8VhTkRhhkOioqAgCtUA5V/?1dmy&urile=wcm%3apath%3a%2Fcnas%2Fcnas%2Fintrebari-frecvente%2Ffrequently%2Basked%2Bquestions
- "Electronic health record" forum: http://forum.des-cnas.ro/
- On Dec 22, 2021, CNAS claims that: over 13.3 million electronic health files were created, to which 27,219 doctors from 12,261 medical institutions connected to the system contributed information.
All medical data, including consultations, referrals, analyses, prescriptions, observation sheets, as well as antecedents and event history, will be recorded safely and permanently. Following the authentication steps, we may check the medical file at any time, from any location with Internet connection (if it has been created).
- Accessing DES (example):


- The Electronic Health Record (DES) is an IT technology that allows consumers to keep a medical history based on documents supplied by doctors and collected in the application. The holder has complete control over access to his own file and may see at any moment who and from where did one obtain the DES's medical data.
- The latest version added the ability for anybody who desires to anonymize their data stored in the DES; following anonymization, only statistical information that cannot be connected to a person is retained in the system. Because anonymization is irreversible, the DES holder no longer has the option of regaining the medical data that was recorded prior to the date of anonymization. However, prior to anonymization, the DES holder might save the information from the personal health file in its own file.
- In addition, a mechanism for escaping anonymization was developed, via which a person can opt to build a new DES, in which the medical data registered by doctors would be gathered, beginning on the day the decision to exit anonymization was made.
- Complete methods for anonymization/exit anonymization can be found on the CNAS website https://cnas.ro/dosar-electronic-de-sanatate/ .
- Apart from the holder, the DES may be accessed by doctors with the patient's agreement to learn about the patient's medical history, allowing for faster and more accurate diagnosis, treatment, and patient monitoring.
- Dosarul are în componență o secțiune de date medicale de urgență, care poate fi accesată fără acordul pacientului. Această secțiune cuprinde datele medicale relevante în cazul unei urgențe, documentele înregistrate în ultimele 6 luni, precum și informațiile pe care proprietarul dosarului le poate completa în secțiunea ‘’antecedente declarate de pacient”.
I.2. INFORMATION COLLECTED FROM PRIMARY (HUMAN) SOURCES
Note: This section will be updated when new data is obtained.
- Source: medical-surgical staff
Today, the following practice is common in hospitals:
The patient has been admitted to Hospital A. The patient's medical history is taken upon admission (investigations).
Hospital A's staff can only see data from their database; they cannot see what the patient did in other hospitals (B,C,D...).
The patient is asked to bring paperwork from previous hospitalizations or doctors.
At admission and discharge, but also along the way, medical personnel spend about 30-40% of their time on paperwork and bureaucratic procedures, rather than allocating all of their time to patient care/treatment.
The patient is given the Discharge Form upon discharge, which states: the patient presented himself at the hospital for...with the symptoms.... He was given/performed....x, y, z operations/Upon discharge, his condition is........ and they are recommended....
REIMBURSEMENTS - expenses/patient - patient has no access to it (FACIAS encountered only one exception, the other days, during the research)
- Source: Patients
A form is given to the patient upon discharge from the hospital. When we go to the hospital, we must bring our previous records.
I.3. THE LEGISLATION GOVERNING THE SCOPE OF THE OBJECTIVE
- LAW no. 45 of March 8, 2019 for the amendment and completion of Law no. 95/2006 on health reform:https://legislatie.just.ro/Public/DetaliiDocumentAfis/211755
- Health Reform Law No. 95 of April 14, 2006: https://legislatie.just.ro/Public/DetaliiDocumentAfis/210075
- ORDER no. 643/489/2021 regarding the amendment and completion of the Order of the Minister of Health and the President of the National Health Insurance House no. 1,123/849/2016 for the approval of the data, information and operational procedures necessary for the use and operation of the patient's electronic health record (DES): https://legislatie.just.ro/Public/DetaliiDocumentAfis/243382
II: Acțiuni planificate de FACIAS, pentru Obiectiv în perioada iulie – septembrie 2022
Action 1: Information request
- Information requested from CNAS
- How many electronic files are currently registered?
- Can data from before the launch of DES be loaded?
- Why do hospitals continue to work without DES, including on documents brought by patients when a medical history is required?
- Is your data sent to the DES system by any healthcare provider (private or public)?
- What conclusions may be drawn for Public Policies six months following the launching of DES?
- Are only service providers under contract with the Health Center eligible to participate in DES?
- Is it possible to enroll in both DES and private health care?
- Despite the availability of DESI, the following practices are still observed in hospitals: The patient is checked into Hospital A and given an anamnesis upon admission. The hospital A staff can only see data from its database; they cannot see what the patient did in other hospitals (B,C,D...). The patient is asked to bring any paperwork from previous hospitalizations or doctors. At admission and discharge, but also along the road, medical workers spend roughly 30-40% of their time on paperwork and bureaucracy, rather than committing all of their time to patient care/treatment. The patient is given the Discharge Form upon discharge, which states: the patient presented himself at the hospital for...with the symptoms... He was given/performed....x, y, z operations/ Upon discharge, his condition is ... and recommendations are ... When do you expect DESI to be functional and beneficial for its intended purpose?
- What are the steps to be taken at this stage for a patient to be aware of the expenditure incurred by the State for the benefit of his/her health?
- Were sanctions imposed on medical service providers (with or without contracts with CNAS) for failing to comply with the legal provisions governing the registration of medical data in the DES? (EHR) (electronic health record) In that case, how many punishments have been imposed thus far?
- How many healthcare providers and/or doctors, out of all doctors and health care providers in the country, comply with their obligation to enter data in the DES?
- Are only service providers under contract with the Health Center eligible to participate in DES?
- Is it possible to enroll in both DES and private health care?
- What laws govern an individual's access to a medical record (please tell us any laws you are aware of)?
Action 2: Pe pagina Facebook a FACIAS: Chestionar pentru a vedea câți români au DES activ:
The URL will be included in the call to action so that everyone can directly check whether or not they can view their medical data.