Skip to content Skip to sidebar Skip to footer

Descrierea necesității soluționării

FACIAS ran the "Be Informed, Not Abused!" project from April 2021 to February 2022.

These issues were revealed, particularly by the approximately 1000 responses to the FACIAS Questionnaire and the over 3000 messages received."

One of the five key difficulties mentioned for which we were asked for citize support in the Health domain is:

  • Pericolul generat de infecțiile intraspitalicești asupra pacienților și faptul că ei nu găsesc ușor informații pe temă, în legătură cu spitalele la care merg, dar nici ce au de făcut pentru prejudiciile generate.

UPDATED OFFICIAL INFORMATION:

Steps in the process of identifying and reporting intrahospital infections:

Competent authorities: Each hospital unit has a designated department (SPIAAM) that reports confirmed instances of nosocomial infections to the county public health directorate (DSP) (called by law IAAM). Competent authorities: Each hospital unit has a designated department (SPIAAM) that reports confirmed instances of nosocomial infections to the county public health directorate (DSP) (called by law IAAM). The hospital unit's management is legally responsible for reporting (Law 3/2021 art 30 paragraph 4). Local DSPs, in turn, report to the National Institute of Public Health (INSP). ANMCS is obligated to analyze IAAM's preventative activity. According to the law, within six months of the implementation of Law 3/2021, the National Committee for the Prevention and Limitation of Healthcare-Associated Infections (CNPLIAAM) should have been constituted. CNPLIAAM, which is coordinated by the Ministry of Health, is (theoretically) in charge of planning, initiating, coordinating, monitoring, and evaluating all measures.

Responsible: The Advisory Board is in charge of penalizing clinicians who have caused IAAM harm at the medical unit level.

Who regulates: In theory, the CNPLIAAM (National Committee for the Prevention and Limitation of Infections Associated with Medical Assistance), which has yet to be constituted despite the fact that the legal deadline has passed.

Who makes the norms: the Ministries of Health and Labor and Social Protection

June 2022- At the request of FACIAS, the Ministry of Labor and Social Protection reported that it had completed its duty, while the Ministry of Health has yet to answer.

Major PROBLEMS identified:

  • Because the penalties for not reporting nosocomial infections (IAAM) are not regulated, not all hospitals report them (they would have been regulated in the Methodological Norms of Law 3/2021, which have not yet been published, despite the fact that they should have been delivered from July to July 2021).

Final Provisions of Chapter XI (regarding methodological norms Law 3/2021):

Article 32

 (2) Within six months of the law's coming into effect, the Ministry of Health, in collaboration with the Ministry of Labor and Social Protection, develops methodological regulations for its implementation, which are authorized by a Government decision.

  • The reports, no matter how superficial, are not available anywhere for citizens to access this information.
Information Source Evolution of nosocomial infections-Reported (not all are reported)
Source-Ministry of Health (http://www.cdep.ro/relatii_publice/site2015.text_presa?pid=12245) 2010 8.105
2011 8.463
2012 8.274
2013 9.296
2014 10.63
2015 12.316
  2016 ?
Source: INSP, CNSISP https://cnsisp.insp.gov.ro/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/BULETIN-AN-2017.pdf https://cnsisp.insp.gov.ro/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Buletin-Informativ-Principalii-indicatori-AN-2017.pdf 2017 19607
Source:INS, taken from SGG, at: http://sgglegis.gov.ro/legislativ/docs/2021/08/_jsd58g912ybfzthkqnc.pdf 2018 20240
2019 23312
2020 23209
  • There is no data to prove that we are tracking the deaths of those who get sick in hospitals, despite the fact that it is critical.
  • There are no public actions that the victim or their relatives can take.

I.2. Information Collected:

  • CNPLIAAM, autoritatea de control, nu a fost înființat încă, deși au trecut peste 6 luni de la termen (Legea 3/2021); cu toate acestea, pe mandatul ministrului Sănătății Ioana Mihăilă a existat draftul HG[1] privind înființarea CNPLIAAM (Centrul Național pentru Prevenirea și limitarea infecțiilor asociate asistenței medicale);


    Possible reasons why many hospitals do not report:
  • lack of epidemiologists
  • There are no penalties for failing to report nosocomial infections.
  • Managers were penalized until 2016 if they disclosed the truth regarding nosocomial infections" (source: Vlad Voiculescu, former Minister of Health[2], 2020)[2], 2020)
  • The DSP's severity in fining and sanctioning cases discourages doctors and hospitals from reporting (Source: Vasile Cepoi, ANMCS president[3], 2019)[3] , 2019)


    Cases of people who died or were harmed by nosocomial diseases that were made public:
  • Un pacient, Paul Costea, afectat de IAAM, a fost despăgubit în 2020 cu 40.000 euro de stat, iar o altă pacientă, Ileana Adriana Totolici se judeca cu Spitalul Bagdasar Arseni ().
  • Alt caz, spital trimis în judecată pentru moartea a trei bebeluși suspectați de infecții nosocomiale () în 2021. 
  • Jurnaliștii de la Libertatea au investigat două cazuri cu: 14 persoane decedate în urma contractării infecțiilor nosocomiale în secția ATI a Spitalului Militar Central la finalul anului 2020 și cu alți  cinci pacienți decedați de la complicații în urma infecțiilor nosocomiale dintr-un spital militar de campanie, în aceeași perioadă (). 
  • Un pacient afectat de atac cerebral a ajuns aproape de moarte în 2021 după ce a contractat infecții nosocomiale (). Avem adresa de e-mail a soției sale și numărul ei de telefon, o putem contacta ([email protected] / 0730.021.119). 

Other useful information:

  • According to Art. 654 para. 2 of Law 95/2006, medical personnel are not liable for losses and injuries sustained while performing their duties if they are caused by...nosocomial infections, unpleasant consequences, and so on.
  • In the first quarter of 2020, the units in the Capital have reported no cases.
  • Order 1.101/2016 replaced the previously existing nosocomial infection methodological criteria (Order 916/2006). 
  • Nu există monitorizarea deceselor celor îmbolnăviți în spitale, deși este de importanță stringentă ().
  • Sindicaliștii din spitale – nemulțumiți că nu există condiții care să prevină răspândirea de infecții nosocomiale în spitalele din România () 
  • President Klaus Iohannis publicly stated that he will ask for explanations for not declaring nosocomial infections in October 2020 cere explicații privind situația nedeclarării infecțiilor nosocomiale, în octombrie 2020 (). 
  • In 2010, Romania ranked #1 in Europe in terms of the number of nosocomial infections.[4].

I.3. Legislation regulating the field of the Objective

For clarification, further information (legislation) from the Law 3/8 January 2021:

Chapter IV Supervision of IAAM

Article 15: The activity of monitoring IAAM within medical units is mandatory and is carried out in accordance with the provisions of the Order of the Minister of Health no. 1.101/2016 approving the Norms for the supervision, prevention, and limitation of infections associated with medical assistance in health facilities.

Chapter XI Final Provisions (ref methodological norms Law 3/2021)

Article 32

(1) Within 3 months from the date of entry into force of this law, the methods of financing medical units and the training of personnel that work directly in the prevention of IAI or in programs for the judicious use of antibiotics shall be approved by Government decision, at the proposal of the Ministry of Health.

(2) Within six months of the law's coming into effect, the Ministry of Health, in collaboration with the Ministry of Labor and Social Protection, develops methodological regulations for its implementation, which are authorized by a Government decision.

(3) In order to ensure the funds necessary for the application of this law, the Ministry of Public Finance is authorized to, upon the proposal of the Ministry of Labor and Social Protection and the Ministry of Health, introduce the changes arising from the application of the provisions of this law in the structure of the state budget, the budget of the Ministry of Labor and Social Protection, as well as the budget of the Ministry of Health. (4) Within 6 months from the date of entry into force of this law, amendments and additions to the specific legislation shall be submitted for approval to the Government or the Parliament, as the case may be, in order to harmonize the provisions contrary to the provisions of this law.

1.3. What we don't know

What is the current and real state of nosocomial infections?

Whether or not the total or partial number of deaths caused by IAAM is known.

What should an infected patient do at the hospital, and what are the treatments? What can it do and who is it intended for?

How is non-reporting of nosocomial illnesses sanctioned (by whom)?

What exactly does not cover the methodological criteria already imposed, according to the Law, in addition to sanctions for non-reporting? (OM 1101)

II: FACIAS action proposals, on Objective 5

Action 1: Inquiries to::

  • Information requested from the Ministry of Health
  1. What legislation governs the continuous, transparent monitoring and reduction of intra-hospital infections ?
  2. Why hasn't the CNPLIAAM been set up yet? When will it be set up?
  3. Do you have any records that contain the Romanian hospitals that have/don't have an epidemiologist?
  4. How many Romanian hospitals do not have an epidemiologist?
  5. What resources do hospitals lacking an epidemiologist have to identify and report nosocomial infections?
  6. Is there an annual statistic, a database of hospital nosocomial infection reports? How do we get to it? Whose job is it to make it happen if it doesn't already exist?
  7. Is it mandatory to disclose nosocomial illnesses under the law? What are the consequences for those who do not submit reports or make them a reality? Who decides on sanctions, and what are they? Is there a centralized situation in place with sanctions?
  8. Do you know why these reports aren't made or are only made superficially? If you are aware of these causes, please share them with us.
  9. Are there statistical reports that reflect the rate of intra-hospital infection mortality in Romania?What is the frequency with which it is conducted? Who creates them? How do we access them?
  10. How may patients who visit a hospital understand exactly what nosocomial infections exist in that hospital?
  11. What steps should a patient who has been infected with AIAM take? Are the tests exclusively performed in hospitals, or may they be performed at home? Who should the patient or family member address to (in case of death)?
  12. How many cases of non-reporting or inadequate reporting of nosocomial infections are sanctioned, given that Law 3 states that these cases are sanctioned in accordance with the methodological criteria for the execution of this law, which have yet to be issued?
  13. How many times has the Romanian state been taken to court in the last five years for cases of nosocomial infections?
  14. How many times has the Romanian state been taken to court in the last five years for cases of nosocomial infections?
  15. How much compensation has the Romanian government paid out in the last five years to persons who have had intra-hospital infections?
  16. What prevention and limitation measures did INSP propose to the Ministry of Health, according to its legal obligations?
  17. According to the law, how has the Ministry of Health collaborated with the ECDC and WHO to ensure the implementation of European and worldwide recommendations on nosocomial infections?

    Information requested from the Romanian Society of Epidemiology::
  1. Do you have an up-to-date situation analysis regarding Romanian hospitals that have and do not have an epidemiologist?
  2. How many Romanian hospitals do not have an epidemiologist?


    Information requested - NATIONAL INSTITUTE OF PUBLIC HEALTH: NAȚIONAL DE SANATATE PUBLICA:
  • Are there statistical reports that reflect the rate of intra-hospital infection mortality in Romania?What is the frequency with which it is conducted? Who creates them? How do we access them?
  • How many hospitals do these reports and how many do not?
  • Do you know why these reports aren't made or are only made superficially? If you are aware of these causes, please share them with us.
  • Do you know why these reports aren't made or are only made superficially? If you are aware of these causes, please share them with us.
  • How may patients who visit a hospital understand exactly what nosocomial infections exist in that hospital?
  • What steps should a patient who has been infected with AIAM take? Are the tests exclusively performed in hospitals, or may they be performed at home? Who should the patient or family member address to (in case of death)?
  • How many cases of non-reporting or inadequate reporting of nosocomial infections are sanctioned, given that Law 3 states that these cases are sanctioned in accordance with the methodological criteria for the execution of this law, which have yet to be issued?
  • How many times has the Romanian state been taken to court in the last five years for cases of nosocomial infections?
  • What prevention and limitation measures did INSP propose to the Ministry of Health, according to its legal obligations?



    Information requested - ANMCS:
  1. Is there an annual statistic, a database of reports of nosocomial infections made by hospitals?
  2. How many hospitals do these reports and how many do not?
  3. Do you know why these reports aren't made or are only made superficially? If you are aware of these causes, please share them with us.
  4. Are there statistical reports that reflect the rate of intra-hospital infection mortality in Romania?What is the frequency with which it is conducted? Who creates them? How can we access them?
  5. How many Romanian hospitals do not have an epidemiologist?
  6. Is it mandatory to disclose nosocomial illnesses under the law? What are the consequences for those who do not submit reports? Who decides on sanctions, and what are they?
  7. How many times has the Romanian state been taken to court in the last five years for cases of nosocomial infections?
  8. How much compensation has the Romanian government paid out in the last five years to persons who have had intra-hospital infections?

Action 2 (august) : Creation of a realistic guide for IAAM patients- legal action steps, court, etc....

Acțiunea 3 (iulie-august) : Dissemination of the Call to Action (already done by FACIAS) - for the collection of data that will lead to the formation of a group of afflicted patients whose interests FACIAS can represent in court.

Action 4 (august):Dissemination of the FACIAS Questionnaire - general public indicates whether or not they were affected by IAAM (the questionnaire is already created)

Action 5: Identification of new allies for the advocacy process dedicated to the Objective (after collecting all the necessary data)

Action 6: Representation of IAAM-affected patients (if they want it)

III. Context (additional information )

Other information sources:

Pg 13: “Surveillance data show that in 2015, 24.7% of Klebsiella pneumoniae bacteria were resistant to carbapenems, an important class of last-line antibiotics for treating bacterial infections. This percentage is much higher than the EU/EEA average (0.5%) and the third highest in the EU/EEA (ECDC, 2017). The Romanian government is now taking steps to develop a national action plan on RAM.

Moreover, the data collected, such as rates of nosocomial infections in hospitals, are not reliable. The National Authority for Health Quality Management, established in 2015, is developing a quality assurance strategy and will extend the accreditation process from hospitals to all healthcare providers."


[1] The Governmental decision draft is available at: https://www.ms.ro/2021/08/30/proiectul-de-hotarare-a-guvernului-privind-infiintarea-comitetul-national-pentru-prevenirea-si-limitarea-infectiilor-asociate-asistentei-medicale/

[2]  Nosocomial infections encountered in Romanian hospitals, an unknown; Digi 24; 2020, 

[3] The average reporting of nosocomial infections in Romania, four times lower than in Europe, according to the ANMCS president, 2019; https://rohealthreview.ro/media-raportarii-infectiilor-nosocomiale-in-romania-de-patru-ori-mai-mica-decat-in-europa-potrivit-presedintelui-anmcs/

[4] How to guard against "criminal" bacteria in hospitals, EVS, 2011:   https://evz.ro/cum-sa-va-paziti-de-bacteriile-criminale-din-spitale-944303.html

© 2022 — FACIAS All rights reserved.

facias
Prezentare generală a confidențialității

Acest site folosește cookie-uri pentru a-ți putea oferi cea mai bună experiență în utilizare. Informațiile cookie sunt stocate în navigatorul tău și au rolul de a te recunoaște când te întorci pe site-ul nostru și de a ajuta echipa noastră să înțeleagă care sunt secțiunile site-ului pe care le găsești mai interesante și mai utile.